In May 2004, when Manmohan Singh was sworn in as India’s 14th Prime Minister, it was a moment of surprise for many. The soft-spoken economist, widely credited with overseeing India’s transformative 1991 economic reforms, was an unexpected choice for the top job, particularly when many speculated that Congress leader Sonia Gandhi might herself step into the role. However, despite the public perception that the position was rightfully hers, Sonia Gandhi chose to step aside and support Singh. It was a decision that, over the years, revealed a deep understanding of her own limitations and a keen awareness of the country’s needs.
A Humble Realization: Sonia Gandhi’s Thought Process
Years after the event, in March 2014, Sonia Gandhi opened up about her decision. Speaking at an event in Mumbai, she shared her thoughts: “I knew my limitations… I knew Manmohan Singh would be a better Prime Minister.”
This candid admission shed light on the inner workings of a leader who had witnessed the country’s political landscape and understood the demands of the top job. Sonia Gandhi’s acknowledgment of her own constraints reflected not just political maturity but a clear vision of what India needed at the time.
Many have speculated about the reasons behind her decision. Was it the intense criticism of her Italian heritage that made her hesitant to accept the post? Could it have been the tragic loss of her husband, Rajiv Gandhi, to an assassination in 1991, which left her children worried for her safety? Or was it the internal dissent within the Congress party? Regardless of the motivations, Sonia Gandhi trusted her “inner voice” and decided that Manmohan Singh was the better choice to lead the nation.
Manmohan Singh’s Steady Leadership: The ‘Accidental Prime Minister’
Manmohan Singh’s tenure as Prime Minister, lasting from 2004 to 2014, was a period marked by both successes and challenges. On the one hand, his leadership helped lay the foundation for India’s economic growth, strengthen the country’s global standing, and implement progressive social policies. On the other hand, Singh’s second term was marred by corruption scandals, slowing growth, and high inflation, all of which contributed to the criticisms he faced.
Despite the challenges, Singh was often criticized by his political opponents for his perceived lack of charisma and decisive action. The BJP, in particular, branded him as a “puppet” Prime Minister, suggesting that he was merely a figurehead while Sonia Gandhi and other Congress leaders pulled the strings. However, Singh never publicly retaliated to these jabs. Instead, he maintained his calm and focused on what he believed was his true responsibility: serving the country.
During his time in office, Singh made a lasting impact on India’s economy, securing the landmark India-US nuclear deal and ensuring the implementation of key policies like the Right to Education Act and the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act. Even when faced with fierce political opposition, Singh’s focus on long-term development goals never wavered.
‘Silent PM,’ ‘Reluctant PM,’ and the Legacy of Manmohan Singh
Despite his significant contributions, Manmohan Singh’s leadership was often overshadowed by constant political attacks. Terms like “silent PM” and “reluctant PM” were frequently used by critics to undermine his effectiveness. These accusations painted him as indecisive, and the Congress party often struggled to counter these attacks effectively.
However, Singh’s response to such criticisms was always measured. In a 2014 interview, he wryly remarked, “I honestly believe that history will be kinder to me than the contemporary media, or for that matter, the opposition parties in Parliament.” Singh’s calm demeanor and his belief in the power of history to judge his legacy reflected his personal resilience and commitment to serving India with integrity.
As history begins to evaluate his time in office, it is clear that Manmohan Singh’s tenure was marked by both remarkable achievements and significant challenges. The reforms he implemented and the decisions he made helped shape India’s trajectory in the global arena. Yet, the controversies and criticisms of his leadership have added complexity to his legacy.
Manmohan Singh
Opened India to the world.
Set stage for India at global high table.
Ended India’s nuclear winter – landmark Indo-US nuclear deal.
Steered India successfully through the global financial crisis.
First PM after Nehru to be returned to office after a full term. pic.twitter.com/e7aKydoilS
— Civil Learning (@CivilLearning1) December 27, 2024A Legacy Remembered: National Mourning for Manmohan Singh
Manmohan Singh’s passing at the age of 92 in December 2024 was met with an outpouring of grief, not just from his colleagues in the Congress Party, but from leaders across the political spectrum and around the world. Prime Minister Narendra Modi, who had regularly interacted with Singh during his tenure as Prime Minister, hailed him as one of the country’s most distinguished leaders. The Times of India described him as the “man who liberated India’s dreams,” acknowledging his role in driving economic liberalization and fostering a vision for a stronger, more self-reliant India.
India declared seven days of mourning following Singh’s death, with a state funeral planned to honor his contributions to the nation. Across the world, former heads of state, including Barack Obama and Angela Merkel, remembered Singh as a scholar, a gentleman, and a leader who had dedicated his life to serving his country. In a fitting tribute, the Indian cricket team wore black armbands during their match in Melbourne, paying their respects to the late former Prime Minister.
A Humble Beginning to Global Recognition
Manmohan Singh’s journey from the small village of Gah (now in Pakistan) to the highest office in India was nothing short of extraordinary. Born in 1932, Singh came from humble beginnings and worked his way up through education, winning scholarships to study at Cambridge and Oxford, where he earned a first-class degree in economics and a doctorate. His career trajectory included significant roles in India’s civil service, as the Governor of the Reserve Bank of India, and as an economist at global organizations such as the United Nations.
Singh’s pivotal role in India’s economic liberalization in 1991, when he served as Finance Minister, was a game-changer. His policy reforms helped pull India out of a severe financial crisis and paved the way for the country’s economic growth over the following decades. When he became Prime Minister in 2004, his leadership helped further propel India’s emergence as a global economic power.
Reflecting on an Extraordinary Life
Manmohan Singh’s life and legacy will be remembered for his intellect, humility, and dedication to the service of his country. From his early struggles in a small village to his role in shaping India’s modern economy, Singh’s story is one of perseverance, resilience, and service. Despite the political criticisms and controversies, his contributions to India’s growth and global standing cannot be overlooked.
As history reflects on his time as Prime Minister, it is clear that Manmohan Singh was much more than a “puppet” Prime Minister. He was a leader who navigated complex challenges with dignity and foresight, always keeping the country’s well-being at the heart of his decisions. His legacy will endure, and in the years to come, India will continue to honor the contributions of this remarkable man.
Read More : Amidst Strong Opposition, ‘One Nation, One Election’ Bill Passes in Lok Sabha
