In a surprising move, Andy Burnham, the Labour Mayor of Greater Manchester, has publicly split with Sir Keir Starmer, leader of the Labour Party, over the call for a national inquiry into grooming gangs. Burnham’s stance is a call for a “limited national inquiry” into historic cases of child sexual exploitation, citing the importance of learning from past reviews conducted at the local level in cities like Manchester, Rochdale, Telford, and Rotherham.
This break comes after a heated debate in Parliament, where Labour MPs were instructed to vote against an amendment that would have triggered such an inquiry. The amendment, introduced by the Conservative Party, had the potential to derail the Government’s broader Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Bill if passed. In Burnham’s view, while the government was right to reject the “opportunistic” form of inquiry suggested by the Tory amendment, there remains a pressing need for a more structured and focused investigation into the grooming gangs issue, particularly to hold authorities accountable for past failures.
Andy Burnham’s Perspective on the Inquiry
During a broadcast with Radio Manchester, Burnham clarified that his call for a national inquiry is not meant to reopen the wounds unnecessarily, but rather to draw on the findings of local reviews and investigate how these issues could be tackled nationally. He referenced the review he commissioned in 2017, which examined child grooming cases in Manchester, Oldham, and Rochdale, concluding that local authorities had failed to protect vulnerable children from abuse. The Mayor emphasized that such an inquiry would compel individuals to testify and potentially face charges, something beyond the scope of his office’s power.
Burnham’s intervention is significant, especially as it contrasts with the official Labour Party stance. Sir Keir Starmer, on the other hand, ordered Labour MPs to vote against the call for a national inquiry. This decision has raised eyebrows and deepened the rift between Burnham and the Labour leadership.
Keir Starmer’s Position and Public Response
The Labour leader’s decision to block the inquiry reflects his position that victims of grooming gangs do not necessarily want another round of investigations but instead want action. This reasoning aligns with Starmer’s broader strategy of focusing on tangible solutions and support for victims rather than reopening past scandals. However, Burnham’s remarks suggest there is a growing divide within the party over the handling of this issue.
The disagreement has further fueled speculation regarding the direction of Labour’s approach to issues of child sexual abuse. Starmer’s absence from the key vote on the matter has also been noted, with some interpreting it as a sign of wavering on the issue. A number of Labour MPs representing areas affected by grooming gangs, such as Telford, Rochdale, and Bradford, were forced to vote against the inquiry, despite the clear need for a thorough investigation in these towns. This has led to calls from some quarters for greater accountability from those in power.
Elon Musk and the Public Debate
The issue of grooming gangs has also entered the realm of public discourse, with figures like Elon Musk weighing in. Musk, a prominent tech billionaire with links to former President Donald Trump, urged the public to pressure MPs into supporting a national inquiry into grooming gangs, citing the need for justice for victims. His intervention has sparked controversy, with figures like David Lammy, the Foreign Secretary, accusing Musk of spreading misinformation and misleading the public.
Musk’s comments have only added fuel to the fire, intensifying the debate over how best to approach the issue of child sexual exploitation and the responsibilities of government and institutions.
Labour MPs in Grooming Gang Areas: How Did They Vote?
Another interesting angle in this debate is the voting behavior of Labour MPs representing constituencies at the heart of the grooming gang scandal. Kemi Badenoch, a Conservative MP, has publicly criticized Labour members from these areas, accusing them of failing to vote in favor of a national inquiry into the abuse of children in their own constituencies.
Towns like Telford, Rochdale, Oldham, and Bradford have been hotspots for high-profile grooming gang cases, often involving men of Pakistani heritage exploiting young girls. The failure of MPs in these areas to support the inquiry has drawn strong criticism, with opponents accusing them of prioritizing party politics over the interests of victims. Badenoch’s comments have highlighted the tension between political expediency and the moral imperative to address the systemic nature of grooming gangs.
The Struggle for Accountability: Why Action Is Needed
This ongoing debate comes at a time when the wider issue of child abuse in the UK remains under scrutiny. The Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse (IICSA), led by Professor Alexis Jay, delivered its final report in 2022, uncovering widespread abuse that has scarred thousands of victims across the country. The report emphasized the failure of both government and institutions to protect vulnerable children from harm.
A tale of two Mayors…
Well done to Labour Mayor Andy Burnham who has today broken with Keir Starmer and Labour MPs, and backed calls for a national rape gangs inquiry.
We might be on different sides of politics but this just proves it shouldnt be a political issue.
A shame… pic.twitter.com/h5Cx47TYtx
— Robbie Moore MP (@_RobbieMoore) January 9, 2025One of the key recommendations from the inquiry was for mandatory reporting of suspected child abuse, a measure that could hold those in positions of trust accountable. This proposal, along with others aimed at improving child protection, remains a point of contention. The government has made progress on some of these reforms, such as introducing the Online Safety Bill and expanding data collection on abuse, but significant work remains. Experts like Lucy Duckworth from the campaign group Act On IICSA are calling for a dedicated child protection authority to oversee and drive forward these reforms.
The issue of compensation for victims and better mental health support for survivors also remains a priority. But with the government’s slow progress on implementing these recommendations, the question remains: will enough be done to protect future generations from similar abuse?
The rift between Burnham and Starmer over the national inquiry into grooming gangs highlights the broader tensions within British politics on how to address systemic child sexual abuse. While some argue that further inquiry will only delay meaningful action, others, like Burnham, believe a more focused and comprehensive investigation is necessary to bring those responsible to justice and ensure proper safeguards are put in place. As this debate continues to unfold, the central question remains: how can the government and opposition parties work together to address the deep-rooted issues surrounding grooming gangs and child exploitation?
The public’s trust in institutions is at stake, and for many victims and survivors, action is long overdue.
Read More: Man Charged with Attempted Murder After Christmas Day Car Attack in London’s West End
